Wednesday, November 7, 2012

CAG functions in a more transparent and independent way


The rumour monger of political class has usurped yet another opportunity to defame the high constitutional office of CAG. CAG’s draft comments in Reliance case are alleged to have again leaked before their presentation to the parliament. However, this time it was not even draft comment of the CAG. Albeit in Digvijay Singh words, this is done by the CAG in pursuance of his political agenda. Such a repeated statement by a seasoned politician who has headed a State Govt. regarding CAG is highly irresponsible. It utterly reflect the ignorance about functioning of Indian Parliamentary system. If not so, it shows Digvijay Singh only sees the fact with jaundiced eyes of politics.
            CAG’s reports are not like budget which are prepared, drafted and printed in a closed door and opened on the day it is presented before the Parliament. The report of CAG is the result of an open and transparent process. The principal of natural justice of ‘right of being heard’ is deep rooted in the functioning of his department. Each and every audit finding are intimated to the all the concerned officers of the functioning department for their clarification. On the basis of clarifications received, which if found acceptable, the audit findings are not considered for inclusion in the CAG’s report. If the clarification is not convincing, the finding are suitable modified with due weightage given to the functioning department viewpoint. In case department’s clarification not received, this fact is also invariably mentioned in the audit comment so that reader may know that it is ex-parte conclusion. Irrespective of the clarification received or not, each and every word of the CAG’s report is supported by evidences known in the audit parlance as key documents.  A lot of energy is spent in ensuring that nothing is commented or concluded which is not supported by key documents. Furthermore, the CAG’s report is result of churning of numerous audit findings. Only those are included in the final report which found deserving to be brought to the notice of parliament. Every such deserving case is brought to the notice of the secretary of the concerned department that this is being considered for inclusion in the CAG’s report. Hence the CAG’s draft report may be leaked by the black sheep in the Govt. department. Last year, Maharashtra Govt., in fact, promised to have a CID enquiry in the alleged leak of CAG’s report on land allotment, but such enquiry did not happened.       
To attribute political agenda to CAG is totally immature and reflects lack of understanding of functioning of democratic polity. CAG is by the very nature of its working cannot be soft on the Govt. He highlights lacunae in the existing system, misuse and undue use of power, mis-utilisation of public fund. Hence, who is not soft on the Govt. automatically pleases the opposition. Therefore, leader form opposition party is made chairman of public account committee which examines the CAG’s report. This is a beautiful arrangement of check and balance.
The CAG’s report is the final product of the CAG’s department. Stages prior to it are a part of process. And thus they cannot be termed as CAG’s comment or report. Instances are also that media is not behaving seriously and ploys in denigrating the CAG’s office. Preliminary audit observation of the cutting edge level officer form CAG’s department have been reported as CAG’s comment. CAG’s is one of the offices which is directly assisting the parliament to keep in check the arbitrariness of the executive action and therefore any conclusion on hear say be best avoided for vibrant and responsible democratic system.
(The views are personal)

Monday, September 3, 2012

Raj please redefine Maharashtra

 A seemingly innocuous letter regarding a normal procedure to be followed between two Governments created a little flutter which was enough for banter buzzing  media houses. However, The Bihar Government should have exercised more restraint in intimidating to launch criminal proceedings against the police of other state for abduction. First of all, the letter brings to my mind the impression of mutual mistrust between two Governments. Such a inter-state relation will not augur well for India who is  facing, day by day, threat of internal strife and subtle external aggression in form of cross border terrorism which has always a inter-state ramification. Given the mode of transport and the intensity of crime taking place these days, unnecessary adherence to the police code of Caurnvallis era will only benefit the criminals. However, this can happen only in case of mutual trust and co-operation. In the current episode, the worst is that  the leaders at the loggerhead are just taking care of their vote bank and relegating nation in the background.

Bihar Govenment was taken umbrage of not about the action of Maharshtra Police, but also of Karnataka who arrested without informing the local police. It is high time that Nitish Kumar should think of whether Bihar is becoming safe heavens for the criminal or some Muslim youth from the middle-Bihar have started straying like that of Azamgarh. Further more, there is also a danger to the image of Nitish Kumar which he has carefully cultivated in the last fifteen years that he is becoming another patron of the policy of minority appeasement. His consistent and strong opposition to the Narendra Modi is only reinforcing such image. If it is so, it is very dangerous for the unity of the country as Kishanganj (chicken neck) is not very far away from Bengladesh.

Raj Thakre rhetoric has made him popular among Marathi youth. He has considerably dented the strong hold of rival Shiv Sena. Notwithstanding of the increasing popularity, Raj Thakre, in my view, is committing a grave mistake in interpreting Maharashtra in a very narrow sense and confining it to the present geographical boundary of the State. The concept transcends beyond it. Maharashtra is a nationalism churning land. The history can be traced back to the days of Shivaji Maharaj who was first to visualize the concept of Maharashtra (if I am not wrong). Baji Rao and his son were also influenced by this idea and inspire by it  posed stiff resistance to the invading army of Afghans. Ideas are flow and geography is static concept. Ideas stifled in a particular territory is termed as jingoism. Being the leader of the youths especially teenagers, Raj should be equally concerned about negative influence gripping youth today. He should also be restless on the listening the news of rave party in rural Maharashtra attended by the teenagers of both sexes consuming and drinking in the dark of night. He has the potential so he should utilize it constructively rather than engaging in verbal duels making life miserable for poor labourers who anyway supports the Maharashtra economy and have no time for politics. He should behave like a statesman rather than a rabble-rouser.

Last but not least, such correspondence between two Governments is always confidential in nature. The question remains as to who leaked the letter.

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Team Anna bang ended in whimper


The popular support garnered in the last year by the anti-corruption movement led by Team Anna, is said to have fizzled out this year. The Government response remained the same both the time. It simply showed the arrogant and disdainful attitude of the ruling party. Media played its hypocritical role as well. Beside, Team Anna is equally responsible for the fatigue of popular upsurge against the corruption which is plaguing the entire nation. It found the solution only and only in one legislation. It carried the view that Jan Lokpal is the only solution and not one of the possible serious alternatives to curb the menace. Ultimately, Team Anna laboring under the delusion of having  become a force to reckon with declared to set up political party of it. Contrary to their stand in the past, they will also play the game rather than crusading for changing the rule of the game.
Team Anna has so far demonstrated itself equally susceptible to opportunitism. In murkier electoral politics of India, their survival in so many opportunistic parties will be contingent upon the flexibility of their stand. It is different matter that so far they have not shown any firm stand as a group. Everyone sings in different tune under one guide called Anna. Team Anna explained to the public that only the face of Government changed in the past but Governance remained the same. But, the fact remains that all were equally good in rhetoric at one point of time. The system itself incentivizes corruption in India. The malaise is deep rooted. It lies in falling standard of public morality and to certain extent constitutional provisions. The reasons for the corruption cannot be exhaustive.  However some are:
Ø  The system of the ‘first past the post system’ of electing representative is the mother of all corruption in India. It has engendered political corruption which also patronizes corruption in administration. The system encourages the political party to form a vote bank which in ultimate analysis is divisive for the nation. The problem in Assam-Bodoland has to be seen in light of this.
Ø  Another source of corruption is the post of Governor which does not have stability of tenure and restrictions to the further appointment. In such scenario the incumbent always toe the line of party high command.
Ø  The appointment of a person as a minister of the same field in which he has business interest. The most important example is 2G scam, pulses import scam.
Ø  There is no justification for not making the CBI or investigative wing of the any police, autonomous. It should be completely delinked form law and order and should be given independence.
Ø  Corruption in administration dwarfs in comparison to political corruption. It is flourishing under the patronage of political masters. The existing anti-corruption bureau and vigilance department can curb this to a great extent if they show the will. The existing provisions of the PC Act is enough to send the shiver down the spine of errant babus.
Ø  The most important being the Macaulaian system of education which prepares a student to just pass an examination without any emphasis on developing national perspective and social responsibility with value orientation and collective responsibility, is the biggest reason of falling standard of public morality.
Ø  Last but not least, the growing sense of consumerism in the society is reason for growing greed, cynicism and sense of mistrust in the society.

Rhetoric apart, Team Anna is also not infallible. When the system is right and people who run it are fallible, you need to be within the system to change it. In other way round, you have to be without to change it or atleast to act as a pressure group to rein it. Team Anna rather than keeping alive the crusade against corruption, has committed fraud on the nation by killing the crusade itself. The bang ended in whimper.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

दुबिधा में दोनों गए माया मिली न राम

पिछली बार टीम अन्ना ने  अपने आन्दोलन से भारत माता की तस्वीर हटा दिया क्योकि ऐसा आरोप लगा की यह तस्वीर तो RSS अपने उत्सवों में इस्तेमाल करती है.  अपने को (छद्म) सेकुलर साबित करने के लिए इन्होने ऐसा नीच कर्म किया. लेकिन इनको यह पता नहीं था  कि  भारत माता की यही तस्वीर सारे हिन्दुस्तान में प्रयोग में लाई जाती है और स्वदेशी आन्दोलन  (१९०६-१०) के समय भी इसका प्रयोग बड़े पैमाने पर हुआ था. फिर भी किन्ही लोगों  का विश्वास  जितने के लिए टीम अन्ना ने  यह तस्वीर हटा दिया.उनके इस कदम से   भारत माता के  इस तस्वीर में जो चिंतन है वह समझने वाले बहुत लोग निराश हुए. लेकिन टीम अन्ना तो वन्दे मातरम का प्रयोग अभी भी कर रही है.  क्या फिर कोई आरोप लगाये की 'वन्दे मातरम' का प्रयोग तो भारत माता के उस तस्वीर में विश्वास करने वाले लोग ही करते है तो क्या टीम अन्ना यह भी कहना छोड़ देगी.  फिर ये क्या कोई विकल्प देंगे. और जिनका विश्वास पाने के लिए उन्होंने ये सब किया उनको किस हद तक खुश रखेंगे. अन्ना को फिर धोती छोड़ पायजामा पर आना पड़ेगा.  टीम अन्ना अब राजनितिक पार्टी बन गयी है. 
अंततः इसका तो हश्र वही होगा 'दुबिधा में दोनों गए माया मिली न राम'. 

Thursday, July 26, 2012

जयतु सदा संस्कृतं, भवतु सदा संस्कृतं

बचपन से ही बहुत इच्छा थी की मैं भी संस्कृत पढूं। कभी मौका नहीं मिला। विद्यालय में संस्कृत की पढाई नहीं होती थी। थोडा बहुत विज्ञानं, कला, वाणिज्य और विधि की पढाई की. हिंदी, मराठी, उड़िया और अंग्रेजी पढ़ी पर संस्कृत नहीं। मन में हमेशा एक क्लेश था। संस्कृत के बिना संतुष्टि नहीं होती थी। संस्कृत सर्व भाषाओँ की जननी है। भारतीय संस्कृति का आधार है। हिन्दू आस्था का मूल है। फिर भी उपेक्षित है। बहुत विद्वान लोग भारतीय जीवन में हो रहे अधोपतन के मूल में संस्कृत की उपेक्षा ही पाते है.
एक दिन वह भी दिन आया की जब संस्कृत सिखने का एक मौका मिला। दस दिनों का निःशुल्क वर्ग था। कितना सीखा : बहुत थोडा या फिर शायद कुछ भी नहीं। फिर भी एक बहुत अच्छी शुरुआत बोलूँगा। अत्यधिक संतुष्टि हुई। प्रारंभिक संस्कृत सीखा। वर्ग में शिक्षक का लगन और शिक्षार्थियों की जिज्ञासा को साधुवाद। सबसे उल्लेखनीय  यह था की शिक्षक तो 25 साल के नवयुवक थे। वास्तविक जीवन में खुद स्नातकोत्तर के छात्र  थे। मैं सोचता था की संस्कृत पढ़ाने वाले बुजुर्ग होते होगे या फिर अधेड़. उससे भी महत्वपूर्ण यह की विद्यार्थियों में आधे से ज्यादा 20 की उम्र तक। ये सब आधुनिक वेशभूषा में आधुनिक विचारों वाले और कॉलेज में अच्छी शिक्षा  प्राप्त करने वाले थे। एक विदेशी महिला का संस्कृत सीखने का प्रयास शायद हमें लज्जित कर जाये। शिक्षक के साथ कुछ अन्य लोग भी धारा प्रवाह संस्कृत बोल रहे थे। कुछ छात्र भी। अश्चार्यजनित अति सुखद अनुभूति हुई। 
यह सब देखकर मैं संस्कृत को मृत भाषा कहने वालों को जवाब दूंगा की संस्कृत फिर से पुनर्स्थापित होगी। जन-जन की भाषा बनेगी। भारत को पुनः एक बार विश्वगुरु का गौरव दिलाएगी। यह कार्य थोडा सुगम हो जाये यदि कुछ सरकारी प्रोत्साहन मिल जाये। लेकिन चिंता की कोई बात नहीं, इन ध्येयावादियों का विश्वास और प्रयास अटल है। 
नमन है संस्कृत भारती को और अन्य उन सबको जो निःस्वार्थ भाव से इस भाषा के प्रसार में लगे हैं। माँ भारती उंहें अदम्य साहस और अटल विश्वास दें।
जयतु सदा संस्कृतं, भवतु सदा संस्कृतं। 

Sunday, June 3, 2012

Martyrdom of Mukhiya Ji: A Result of State Failure




Now owner can not till the land
The death of Mukhiya Ji is being seen by many as a start of new chapter in the history of caste clashes in Bihar which has been in calm for a decade. He formed Ranvir Sena in mid nineties by amalgamating the fringe private armies to counter the threat of land grabber led by CPI-ML, IPF and MCC. Raising a private army was in reaction to red flag which was enough warning to stop
Red cadets waiting for order to act with venegeance
tilling the land. In the aftermath what ensued was a series of blood bath in the Sone Basin. The Ranvir Sena became the discussion point of sophomore journalists who always talked it as a representative of higher caste aggressive stand. At the same time, we rarely find any reference to IPF, MCC and CPI-ML. The rise of private armies by both the land-owner and land-less and internecine war between them, may be seen in different way. For a person with Marxist lineage, it was case study of struggle between bourgeois and proletariat and precursor to ‘Total Revolution’. For newly awakened casteists, it was only a persecution of lower castes. For zealots, it was an act of pure revenge. For others, it was the result of wide spread unemployment, poverty, illiteracy and very low degree of urbanization and migration. For an administration expert, it was a classical example of failure of state machinery. 
Mukhiyaji who organised Ranvir Sena to counter red terror

                                                                           The reference ‘private army’ itself is a proof that State has failed in ensuring safety of life and fair distribution of wealth. The rise of Ranvir Sena has to be seen in the background of journey of democratic Bihar since independence. It cannot be seen only as reactionary force to gun wielding Red cadets which propagated annihilation by cutting short by six inches. The first Government of the Bihar was led by Dr. Krishna Singh who unlike some big leaders of that time was not a visionary. In most of the other States some efforts, albeit half hearted, were taken towards land reform. However, it was almost neglected and any suggestion towards it fiercely resisted. Administration was almost run on the caste line. Due to high population density, pressure on the land was too heavy to accommodate everyone in the absence of alternate employment of both land-owner and land-less. State was non-functional in almost every aspect. The absence of facilities of public health, education, physical infrastructure affected every people and caste. Naturally, the worst sufferers were the poor who could not afford the private services in absence of public one. Growing awareness among the marginalized as to their basic right of livelihood with dignity compounded with the State failure and utter disparity became the fertile ground for growth of Maoist doctrine. The people who ruled the Bihar in the initial phase should show sagacity in accepting the fact that their myopic, ungenerous and self-centered attitude in administration resulted in an opportunity lost in making Bihar modern. The rise of Lalu was not sudden but a culmination of frustration, a seething anger which burst into his famous statement “Shave BHU-RA BAA-LA. He rode the popularity chart by becoming the messiah of poor and down-trodden. It is different fact he immediately forgot mandate given to him. He fantasized the marginalized (not OBCs) about false sense of empowerment. At the same time the appointment of some of the officers who were hostile to the caste who were earlier the dominant caused frustration. At this time one group was asserting itself under the banner of Red flag and other faced gloomy future ahead for their coming generation and treated land as treasure to be saved at any cost. It was the time when Bihar was burning and Nero along with its entire posse of police force was busy in political tamasha. The State machinery was totally failed. In this state of despondency and chaos, intelligentsia instead of vehemently condemning and raising public awareness, tacitly supported the side to which they belonged. Some of the carnage alleged like Bara to have been State sponsored. In such a chaotic and gloomy atmosphere, Mukhiyaji emerged as a person who countered the Red threat in their language. In the struggle the blood fell mostly of the Bhumihar’s and Mussahar’s. Hence, the frail looking personality became hero when the local administration failed. 
        Like the caste carnage of eighties-ninties, the genesis of every evil gripping Bihar can be traced in to State failure. However, is the murder is return of the dark era? Not so. Much water has flown in Sone since then and people sitting in either side of the fence should know the futility of making the land Butcher’s altar. The holding of land has been fragmented and the ground reality of land holding today is totally different from what it was sixty years back. The poor are poor because the State has failed to reach to them. This deprivation discontent will continue until their economic position is uplifted. Political consciousness without economic upliftment will only result in social discord. The young intelligential from Bihar spread across the globe should take the lead position rather than remaining silent. The road rampage of youngsters during the last possession of the Mukhiyaji is ominous. If caste-consciousness in the form of other-caste hatred is not annihilated, blood sucker ghost may again return in the rice bowl of Bihar. The only solution is strengthening public administration and law & order, effective delivery mechanism and quality education. Sushashan will not be a reality if only road is built.

At last:
 We the people should know that our nation has suffered a lot in the past due to caste. The enemy is still at our door but we cannot see him. This time he is trying to enter out country not by carrying sword in his hand. The strategy is subtle and totally different. Beware, we should not become ploy in their hand. We should become a a strong Hindu society by treating every Indian as our brother to make a strong Indian Nation. Let us annihilate the caste consciousness and caste ignominy. 

Sunday, March 4, 2012

Shri Ram and Shri Ram Janmabhoomi: A nationalist perspective


It is always said by the Congress and other so called secular brigade that some fanatics of Sangh Parivar razed the Babri mosque and believed by many including Hindu and Muslims. It is not surprising to them who understand the ingenuous psyche of the Indian populace. But what is of paramount importance of Ayodhya Ram temple is to see it in correct perspective. It has been misinformed by the psedo-secular political leaders that it was a communal act. Assuming so is like missing tree for woods. Had Hindu been so communal and building temple being only agenda for them, the mosques which are in Hindu-dominated areas for so many years would not have remained as pristine and respectful. If this was the Hindu people who pulled down the Babri mosque, they would have equally dared to destroy other mosques in other parts of India. No one spared a thought to think why those karsevaks whose only aim was to destroy the Babri mosque did not even touch other mosque in Ayodhya. However, it is also unfortunate that the people who led the movement i.e. Sadhus and some political leader failed to convey the real meaning of the Ayodhya movement.
            India was invaded by Babar in 1524. He ruled Delhi for merely five years. In this period he laid the strong foundation of the Mughal rule in India. In history, Baber, rather than a king, is better known as war commander. If anybody read Babernama, He would know, how He kept charging and motivating his soldiers. His intention for invading would be crystal clear. Why he got the title of Ghazi by making the mound of one lakh capitulated head of Hindu kafirs (they were our ancestor who did not budge from their belief).  Why he ultimately destroyed the Ram Temple? It was a political act of his to lay the seeds of Mughal rule. It was a nationalist act for those who try to build a temple by clearing some concrete structure from the site which they believed to birth site of their God. During his first three years of struggle in India, Babar was fully clear of the idea that except by mentally and psychologically subjugating the Hindu, long lasting rule is not possible. He chose Lord Ram. It was clear to him, that it was this Name which binds Indian. His name was used for worship, address, salutation; and avoidance too. He was ideal for them as a son, brother, husband, soldier, king and human being. Indian people take pride in His name and character. He was hero of Hindu nation. He was source of inspiration for them. It was His name which moved Indian people. Indian people saw ‘toddler Ram’ in their toddler children, ‘son Ram’ in their sons and Raja Ram in their king. Indian women saw in their husband, Lord Ram, who remain faithful, caring and loving towards them and rescue them from any sort of adversity. Hence, Baber was in no doubt that Lord Ram was not only a God for the Indian people but. His was a national personality revered by the entire Hindu nation for the life He lives and examples set. Hence, by attacking the revered place, Baber (or Mir Baqi) not only performed his religious duty of defacing idol of kafirs but also attacked the prestige, pride and esteem of Indian nation. This was a humiliation on Indian/ Hindu nation. Psychological assault is more grievous and long lasting than physical assault. Rest is history. And, it is truly said that history repeats itself if we fail to learn from it.
            Furhtermore, He was the among the first originators of the concept of Janmabhumi (जननी जन्मभूमिश्च स्वर्गादपि गरीयसी) and accorded all respect and dignity to it. He unified the entire country and developed the concept of nation. He protected the land from the foreign country which always tried to invade to create internal disturbances and destroy its culture. The same type of assault the India is always facing today in form of terrorism, naxalism, religious conversion and unwarranted western influence. In this endeavour, He took the help of those people who were marginalized like Nishad, Bhil, Kol, Kirat, Vanar and Bhalu. Even today India cannot be a strong nation if marginalized people are not taken in to mainstream. Further, given the state of governance today, we really need a alternative called 'Ram Rajya' (not with political overtones).
 Let us make strong India.
चलो एक मजबूत भारत बनाएं.