Wednesday, November 7, 2012

CAG functions in a more transparent and independent way


The rumour monger of political class has usurped yet another opportunity to defame the high constitutional office of CAG. CAG’s draft comments in Reliance case are alleged to have again leaked before their presentation to the parliament. However, this time it was not even draft comment of the CAG. Albeit in Digvijay Singh words, this is done by the CAG in pursuance of his political agenda. Such a repeated statement by a seasoned politician who has headed a State Govt. regarding CAG is highly irresponsible. It utterly reflect the ignorance about functioning of Indian Parliamentary system. If not so, it shows Digvijay Singh only sees the fact with jaundiced eyes of politics.
            CAG’s reports are not like budget which are prepared, drafted and printed in a closed door and opened on the day it is presented before the Parliament. The report of CAG is the result of an open and transparent process. The principal of natural justice of ‘right of being heard’ is deep rooted in the functioning of his department. Each and every audit finding are intimated to the all the concerned officers of the functioning department for their clarification. On the basis of clarifications received, which if found acceptable, the audit findings are not considered for inclusion in the CAG’s report. If the clarification is not convincing, the finding are suitable modified with due weightage given to the functioning department viewpoint. In case department’s clarification not received, this fact is also invariably mentioned in the audit comment so that reader may know that it is ex-parte conclusion. Irrespective of the clarification received or not, each and every word of the CAG’s report is supported by evidences known in the audit parlance as key documents.  A lot of energy is spent in ensuring that nothing is commented or concluded which is not supported by key documents. Furthermore, the CAG’s report is result of churning of numerous audit findings. Only those are included in the final report which found deserving to be brought to the notice of parliament. Every such deserving case is brought to the notice of the secretary of the concerned department that this is being considered for inclusion in the CAG’s report. Hence the CAG’s draft report may be leaked by the black sheep in the Govt. department. Last year, Maharashtra Govt., in fact, promised to have a CID enquiry in the alleged leak of CAG’s report on land allotment, but such enquiry did not happened.       
To attribute political agenda to CAG is totally immature and reflects lack of understanding of functioning of democratic polity. CAG is by the very nature of its working cannot be soft on the Govt. He highlights lacunae in the existing system, misuse and undue use of power, mis-utilisation of public fund. Hence, who is not soft on the Govt. automatically pleases the opposition. Therefore, leader form opposition party is made chairman of public account committee which examines the CAG’s report. This is a beautiful arrangement of check and balance.
The CAG’s report is the final product of the CAG’s department. Stages prior to it are a part of process. And thus they cannot be termed as CAG’s comment or report. Instances are also that media is not behaving seriously and ploys in denigrating the CAG’s office. Preliminary audit observation of the cutting edge level officer form CAG’s department have been reported as CAG’s comment. CAG’s is one of the offices which is directly assisting the parliament to keep in check the arbitrariness of the executive action and therefore any conclusion on hear say be best avoided for vibrant and responsible democratic system.
(The views are personal)

No comments:

Post a Comment