Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Team Anna bang ended in whimper


The popular support garnered in the last year by the anti-corruption movement led by Team Anna, is said to have fizzled out this year. The Government response remained the same both the time. It simply showed the arrogant and disdainful attitude of the ruling party. Media played its hypocritical role as well. Beside, Team Anna is equally responsible for the fatigue of popular upsurge against the corruption which is plaguing the entire nation. It found the solution only and only in one legislation. It carried the view that Jan Lokpal is the only solution and not one of the possible serious alternatives to curb the menace. Ultimately, Team Anna laboring under the delusion of having  become a force to reckon with declared to set up political party of it. Contrary to their stand in the past, they will also play the game rather than crusading for changing the rule of the game.
Team Anna has so far demonstrated itself equally susceptible to opportunitism. In murkier electoral politics of India, their survival in so many opportunistic parties will be contingent upon the flexibility of their stand. It is different matter that so far they have not shown any firm stand as a group. Everyone sings in different tune under one guide called Anna. Team Anna explained to the public that only the face of Government changed in the past but Governance remained the same. But, the fact remains that all were equally good in rhetoric at one point of time. The system itself incentivizes corruption in India. The malaise is deep rooted. It lies in falling standard of public morality and to certain extent constitutional provisions. The reasons for the corruption cannot be exhaustive.  However some are:
Ø  The system of the ‘first past the post system’ of electing representative is the mother of all corruption in India. It has engendered political corruption which also patronizes corruption in administration. The system encourages the political party to form a vote bank which in ultimate analysis is divisive for the nation. The problem in Assam-Bodoland has to be seen in light of this.
Ø  Another source of corruption is the post of Governor which does not have stability of tenure and restrictions to the further appointment. In such scenario the incumbent always toe the line of party high command.
Ø  The appointment of a person as a minister of the same field in which he has business interest. The most important example is 2G scam, pulses import scam.
Ø  There is no justification for not making the CBI or investigative wing of the any police, autonomous. It should be completely delinked form law and order and should be given independence.
Ø  Corruption in administration dwarfs in comparison to political corruption. It is flourishing under the patronage of political masters. The existing anti-corruption bureau and vigilance department can curb this to a great extent if they show the will. The existing provisions of the PC Act is enough to send the shiver down the spine of errant babus.
Ø  The most important being the Macaulaian system of education which prepares a student to just pass an examination without any emphasis on developing national perspective and social responsibility with value orientation and collective responsibility, is the biggest reason of falling standard of public morality.
Ø  Last but not least, the growing sense of consumerism in the society is reason for growing greed, cynicism and sense of mistrust in the society.

Rhetoric apart, Team Anna is also not infallible. When the system is right and people who run it are fallible, you need to be within the system to change it. In other way round, you have to be without to change it or atleast to act as a pressure group to rein it. Team Anna rather than keeping alive the crusade against corruption, has committed fraud on the nation by killing the crusade itself. The bang ended in whimper.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

दुबिधा में दोनों गए माया मिली न राम

पिछली बार टीम अन्ना ने  अपने आन्दोलन से भारत माता की तस्वीर हटा दिया क्योकि ऐसा आरोप लगा की यह तस्वीर तो RSS अपने उत्सवों में इस्तेमाल करती है.  अपने को (छद्म) सेकुलर साबित करने के लिए इन्होने ऐसा नीच कर्म किया. लेकिन इनको यह पता नहीं था  कि  भारत माता की यही तस्वीर सारे हिन्दुस्तान में प्रयोग में लाई जाती है और स्वदेशी आन्दोलन  (१९०६-१०) के समय भी इसका प्रयोग बड़े पैमाने पर हुआ था. फिर भी किन्ही लोगों  का विश्वास  जितने के लिए टीम अन्ना ने  यह तस्वीर हटा दिया.उनके इस कदम से   भारत माता के  इस तस्वीर में जो चिंतन है वह समझने वाले बहुत लोग निराश हुए. लेकिन टीम अन्ना तो वन्दे मातरम का प्रयोग अभी भी कर रही है.  क्या फिर कोई आरोप लगाये की 'वन्दे मातरम' का प्रयोग तो भारत माता के उस तस्वीर में विश्वास करने वाले लोग ही करते है तो क्या टीम अन्ना यह भी कहना छोड़ देगी.  फिर ये क्या कोई विकल्प देंगे. और जिनका विश्वास पाने के लिए उन्होंने ये सब किया उनको किस हद तक खुश रखेंगे. अन्ना को फिर धोती छोड़ पायजामा पर आना पड़ेगा.  टीम अन्ना अब राजनितिक पार्टी बन गयी है. 
अंततः इसका तो हश्र वही होगा 'दुबिधा में दोनों गए माया मिली न राम'.