Saturday, July 27, 2013

भारत रत्न का मौजूदा विवाद

भारत रत्न पुरस्कार शुरू से ही विवादित रहा है. कुछ संविधानिक विशेषज्ञ इसे संविधान के अनुच्छेद १८ का उल्लंघन मानते है. वैसे यह सत्य है कि यह सम्मान एक उपाधि नहीं है लेकिन हम भारतीय तो इससे सम्मानित ब्यक्ति के लिए इसे उपाधि के तौर पर ही इस्तेमाल करते है चाहे वह हमारे संविधान निर्माता के लिए क्यों न हो.  यह कोई पदवी भी नहीं है फिर भी इसके साथ राजकीय विशेषाधिकार और सम्मान जुड़े हुए हैं.

अमर्त्य सेन द्वारा नरेन्द्र मोदी का विरोध करने के बाद कुछ लोग ऐसा कह रहे है कि भारत रत्न से सम्मानित ब्यक्ति को सीधी राजनीत से परहेज करना चाहिये.  वैसे यह एक बहुत बड़ा झूठ है कि कोई भी भारत रत्न प्राप्त व्यक्ति भारतीय राजनीति में सीधी दखलअंदाजी नहीं करता। इसकी शुरुआत तो भारतीय राजनीती के शिरमौर और परिवारवाद के जनक नेहरु और गाँधी के समय से ही हो गयी थी. नेहरु (१९५५) और इंदिरा गाँधी (१९७१) में अपने आपको ही भारत रत्न से अलंकृत किया। ये उस समय भारत रत्न के चयन समिति में थे जब इनको यह पुरस्कार मिला। इंदिरा गाँधी ने तो भारत रत्न से अलंकृत होने के बाद भी देश में आपातकाल थोपा और अपने राजनीतिक विरोधियों के लिए दमनकारी नीति का प्रयोग किया।

जब इन्ही के वंशज को भारत रत्न देने की बात हुयी तो कांग्रेस्सियों को लगा कि इनके उपलब्धि तो कुछ नहीं है और ऐसे में यह पुरस्कार एक विवाद पैदा करेगा। अतः इनके साथ सुभाष चन्द्र बोस को मरणोपरांत यह पुरस्कार देने की घोषणा हुयी। लेकिन उनके परिवार वालों ने इसे मना कर दिया क्योंकि सरकार ने कोई साक्ष्य उपलब्ध नहीं करा सकी कि सुभाष चन्द्र बोस की मृत्य हो चुकी है.

अतः भारत रत्न सम्मान शुरू से ही राजनीत के चलते विवादास्पद रहा है और अगर उन लोगो की सूचि बनाई जाये तो यह जगह कम पड़ेगा। हां यह स्पष्ट कर देना आवश्यक है कि भारत रत्न सम्मान में उचित सुधार NDA के शासन में हुए और उस समय किसी भी राजनीतिक व्यक्तित्व को यह सम्मान नहीं दिया गया. इस समय सम्मानित ब्यक्ति थे: एस एस सुब्बुलक्ष्मी (१९९८), सी सुब्रमनियम (१९९८), जय प्रकाश नारायण (१९९८), पंडित रविशंकर (१९९९), अमर्त्य सेन (१९९९), गोपीनाथ बारदोलोई (१९९९), लता मंगेशकर (२००१) और उस्ताद बिस्मिल्लाह खान (२००१) . इसमें से जय प्रकाश नारायण और गोपीनाथ बारदोलोई राजनीतिक क्षेत्र से थे लेकिन उनकी मृत्य बहुत पहले हो चुकी थी. उल्लेखनीय है कि गोपीनाथ बारदोलोई एक कांग्रेसी नेता थे.

अंत में:
मैं अपने आपको इस योग्य नहीं समझता कि अमर्त्य सेन के राजनीतिक दृष्टिकोण और अर्थशास्त्र में उनकी प्रतिभा पर कुछ आक्षेप करूं लेकिन कहने वाले तो ये भी कहते है की उनकी एक पत्नी एम्मा जोर्जिना रोथचैल्ड (Emma Georgina Rothchild) विश्व प्रसिद्ध और विश्व के आर्थिक और बैंकिंग क्षेत्र में महत्वपूर्ण प्रभाव रखने वाले Rothchild परिवार से आती हैं और यह परिवार नोबल पुरस्कार के चयन समिति में भी अपने पैठ रखता है. 

Friday, July 19, 2013

Same Story, contrary presentation by two esteemed dailies

Facts are not what we see, but how we observe. How is observed is mostly a result of our mental perception which is caused by individual's outlook resulting from the societal and family environment. Newspapers are the most powerful opinion-builder as they present their views to cross section of society through their editor's prism. It is a great dismay when a reputed and most trusted newspaper presents a story which is totally one sided and also not in the interest of the society.
Today(19.11.2013) I have interesting reading of the same story on the cover page of the two newspaper which I like the most- The Indian Express and The Free Press journal. Though the story is same but it gave the two strikingly different inference. Reading between the line and subtleties used may take you a different conclusion. Take note:

1. In the Indian Express the headline on the cover page is "At least 4 killed as BSF men open fire on protesters in J&K town"  whereas the same thing is presented in the Free Press journal as "6 killed as mob attacks BSF camp in valley". The difference is too clear to point it out.

2. The first para graph has more glaring differences. The Indian Express reports as " At least four people were killed and 44 injured after the Border Security Force and Jammu and Kashmir Police fire at a mob that allegedly attacked a BSF post in Gool in Ramban district. The Free Press Journal reports " six people were killed and 44 others were injured in stone pelting and resultant firing when a mob attacked a BSF Ramban district". Here, the presentation is such that in first the victim is people and second the victim is security forces. Further, it is also interesting to observe that the Indian Express used the word 'allegedly' and it is surprising that this newspaper has no confirmed sources to ascertain whether mob attack took place on BSF post or not.

3.The Indian Express reports in subsequent para" the mob was protesting the alleged manhandling by BSF personnel of local imam, followed by reported desecration of the Holi Quran the previous night" whereas the Free Press writes "the immediate provocation for the mob attack was alleged BSF high-handedness: the local imam on Wednesday night. The next day the border Security Force jawans allegedly opened fire when angry locals tried to storm their camp". Here, it is interesting to the read the Indian Express that the manhandling by BSF was 'alleged' but it was followed by 'reported' desecration of Quran. How the newpaper is not confirmed about the the first (BSF mishandling) but confirmed about desecration of Quran (as it has used word 'reported' for it) which also caused by BSF. If the first is alleged then second should also be the same. Such reporting has all the material for fomenting communal discontent. 

I hope such reputed and circulated daily like Indian Express should exercise more responsibility and does not fish in the troubled water. It is not to suggest that security forces should not be criticised for their high handedness but the story should not be biased and cause communal discontent. 

The lesson:
Take any news article like a pinch of salt and read between the line and notice subtleties.

Monday, July 8, 2013

A hidden message in the fall out to Ishrat Jahan encounter case


Anti-corruption activists are always vocal in their demand agaisnt the legal safeguard given to the public servants. In fact, this was the demand of the Anna team in their Jan Lokpal Bill that the power to sanction proceeding against the public servant should vests with the Lokpal and not with the departmental authority. The reason they sought is that the sanction on many occasions are withhold on the frivolous ground as a result of which tainted public servants go unpunished. Under Prevention of Corruption Act, no court shall take cognizance of any offence alleged to have been committed by a public servant, except with the previous sanction of the Govt. This clause has been incorporated so that a public servant performs his legal duties in a fair manner with independence and without fear.
The role of Rajendra Kumar, Joint Director in IB, in Ishrat Jahan encounter is yet to emerge clearly. Though his name has been mentioned in the charge-sheet and his role in the allegedly fake encounter clearly delineated, he has not been charge-sheeted. The reason being the sanction has not been given by the Home Ministry. The CBI is investigating only the encounter and not the antecedents of the victims. Even the Govt. has earlier taken clear stand that Ishrat Jahan was indeed on a terror mission. As per our constitution, no person can be deprived of his life without the procedure established by law. Therefore, even a dreaded criminal deserves a fair trial and cold blood murder is legally wrong. Thus, our same criminal justice system ensured fair trial of Azmal Kasab. But, it is also true that in all democracies based on the principle of justice and liberty carry out controlled killing of the anti-nationals. In such cases, pragmatism demands so. No other country in the world faces threat of the magnitude India faces on its integrity and internal security. However, there need to be effective oversight on the performance of the secretive agencies. Given the vitiated political climate in the country where even the national threats are communalized and politicized, it is easier to make public servants a prey to the arrogant political masters if such a safeguard is not available. Had this not been the case, Rajendra Kumar must have been made an accused for the crime which was though legally wrong but was also call of his duty.  This case has vindicated that Govt. servant needs to have safeguard for their impartial and independent performance of duty and as and when any such demand would be raised, this episode shall be premonitory.