Monday, September 26, 2011

हिन्दू बनाम बौद्ध: मेरे एल्लोरा भ्रमण के अनुभव से

          मेरे मित्र श्री नितिन गौतम जी का बहुत दिनों से आग्रह था कि मै कभी औरंगाबाद घुमने आऊं. जब मुझे पिछले हफ्ते कार्यालय के कार्य से औरंगाबाद  जाने का मौका मिला तो मै सपरिवार चल पड़ा. एक साथ तीन उद्देश्यों कि पूर्ति हुई. कार्यालय का कार्य भी हुआ, दो परिवारों का आपस में मिलना भी हो गया और साथ में साप्ताहिक छुट्टियों में विश्व प्रसिद्ध अजंता और एल्लोरा घूमना भी हो गया.
         एल्लोरा अपने आप में एक मिसाल है भारत की धार्मिक और वैचारिक सहिष्णुता की. एल्लोरा के गुफा समूहों में बौद्ध, जैन और हिन्दू विश्वास के शिल्पों का एक साथ एक जगह पर होना इस तथ्य का 
प्रतिपादक  है कि भारत में अभिव्यक्ति कि स्वतंत्रता, धार्मिक सहिष्णुता और वैचारिक ताल मेल की संस्कृति अति प्राचीन है जिसे हमारे आज के संविधान में सिर्फ लिपिबद्ध किया गया है. अतः इनका खासकर बौद्ध और हिन्दू का आपसी संघर्ष और परस्पर विरोध के तौर पर प्रतिपादित करना एकदम बेमानी है. आजकल एक प्रचलन हो गया है कि बौद्ध धर्मं का  भारत से लुप्त होने का कारण हिन्दू (ब्राहमण) धर्मं द्वारा किये जाने वाले सांस्कृतिक और वैचारिक अतिक्रमण था. ये भी काफी जोर से प्रचारित किया जाता है कि बौद्ध धर्मं का लोप हिंदूवादी अत्याचारों से भी हुआ और दोनों में सिर्फ संघर्ष  ही था. वर्ण व्यवस्था से लाभान्वित लोगो ने इसे बढ़ने नहीं दिया, इत्यादि.
           इस धारणा को मै सत्य मानु तो मेरे मन-मस्तिष्क में एक एक सवाल आता है कि बौद्ध के दो अति महत्वपूर्ण तीर्थ स्थान बोध गया और सारनाथ हिन्दुयों के दो अति महत्वपूर्ण तीर्थ स्थान गया और काशी के निकट हैं. यदि सही में बौद्ध के लुप्त होने का कारण हिन्दुयों (ब्राह्मणों) कि कुटिलता और अत्याचार था तो ये स्थान अपना अस्तित्व कैसा बचा पाए? एल्लोरा के बौद्ध गुफा कैसे सुरक्षित रहे? अजंता जो कि हिन्दुयों के एक महत्वपूर्ण तीर्थ स्थान नासिक के समीप है फिर भी किसी आक्रमण के चिह्न अपने साथ नहीं लिए है और कालवश ही क्षतिग्रस्त हुए है. एक अन्य स्थान लेन्यादरी (जुन्नर) में पेशवा ने गणपति मंदिर का जीर्णोद्धार करते समय उसी बरामदे में स्थित चैत्य को क्यों नहीं नष्ट किया. 
       तो फिर क्या कारण थे बौद्ध धर्म भारत से लुप्त हो गया. ऐसा धर्म  जिसका प्रभुत्व संपूर्ण भारतीय समाज पर था. या फिर इसने हिन्दू धर्म  और इसके मान्यताओं को इस प्रकार अंगीकार किया कि अपना स्वतंत्र अस्तित्व ही खो बैठा? या फिर जीवन के प्रति निराशावादी (निर्वित्तिवादी) दृष्टिकोण और सन्यास पर अत्यधिक जोर को लोगों ने भारत के स्वर्णिम काल में त्यागना शुरू कर दिया?  या फिर राजकीय प्रश्रय ने बौद्ध संघो को भ्रष्टाचार का अड्डा बना दिया. मेरी समझ से बौद्ध के भारत से लुप्त होने का सिर्फ एक कारण देना उतना ही कठिन है जितना कि इस बात का उत्तर देना है कि भारत में जाती-व्यस्वस्था कैसे पनपी.







                         (मैंने जितना समझा अजंता के बारे में अगले ब्लॉग में)



Sunday, September 11, 2011

Side effects of anti-corruption policies in Bihar


           Enactment of Bihar Special Courts Act and consequential confiscation of ill-gotten property of Shri SS Verma is a defining moment and shows the seriousness of Government of Bihar in curbing corruption. NDA Governemnt also kept its promise it made during last election. This step of Bihar is also showing the way to the nation which is also equally gripped with corruption. Confiscation of ill-gotten property and throwing it for public use will surely act as a very strong deterrent against corruption. However, opening a primary school in a seized residential house gives an indication that though the Government is serious about tackling corruption but at the same time it is overlooking primary education.
            Design requirement for a school building is altogether different from a residential building. A school building design should address various aspects of the education vision of the school. Each space should be seen from the lens of right of the child for education which also encompasses overall personality development and broadening his outlook towards society. A school building should not be visualized a mere collection of room in a concrete building. Outdoor space which may contain play ground, garden and place of mutual interaction is also important for child development. It should be sensitively developed while planning a primary school.
            As seen from the photographs in the media the seized property may have more than enough space for the indoor study in a primary school. But, in a residential house, most rooms are inter-connected. In such cases, if a class breaks or a child has to go for toilet, in all possibility it will disturb the adjoining class. Definitely, in this case also toilet would have been constructed as required for residential use. Hence, they would fall short of requirement of primary school when children will rush for toilet when class breaks. In a residential house, there is no differentiation for gents and ladies lavatories.  If school is opened in such houses it will also to some extent discourage the girls.
                        The matter is still pending in the Supreme Court. Hence, when the children are sent for school in such building where they are daily told by teachers that this building is constructed by the illegal money and if the matter is finally decided in favour of the accused, this may cause impressionable mind who are not fully able to fully understand the judicial process with a impression that the nothing wrong will happen if you have money. Definitely, reverse is equally true. But, in my view, it the school is to open it is better to wait till the final outcome of the case.
Thanks.

                                                                                                           
                                               
                                                                        

Sunday, September 4, 2011

An Epilogue of Arakshan


Last night I saw the movie ‘Arkanshan. However, the issue of caste-based reservation remained in the background in the movie, albeit the way it has led to commercialization of education in India is indeed a novelty in the story.
            I could not find any thing in the movie which was derogatory to any community or caste. Some of the dialogues, which Saif Ali, as a protagonist,has said might have been the basis of objections raised by certain persons but they are not different from what is being said by the leaders from those castes/ class indulging in identity politics. The dialogues from his mouth in favour of reservation (caste-based) were written and acted so well that, lastly, it was more effective and appealing than the dialogue against reservation (caste-based) delivered by Pratik Babbar. The cacophony of the outcry against the movie leading to its ban in three States  reflected the prejudiced mind with which we take a issue of such enormity and also immaturity of the political leadership.
            The movie is misleading on one point. It linked 27 per cent with Scheduled Caste reservation. 27 per cent reservation for OBCs was the flash point in Indian polity which resulted into emergence of caste centric political parties. But, Scheduled Castes were not beneficiary of it. Reservation for SCs & STs has been a reality since independence and Indian society had come to the terms with it as an instrument to do away with years of injustice. 27 per cent reservation for OBCs to certain extent resulted in overall opposition to the reservation policy as such. The way backward classes were defined and the castes included at the time of every election and implementation of this policy as a mean to create vote-bank produced intense discontent. Reservation for SCs/ STs  is mistakenly viewed by  many as a new concession to the them in the aftermath of 27 per cent reservation . The film also held such view. In fact, many persons from dalit community feel that 27 per cent reservation acted against the interest of SCs. SCs are the real beneficiary of the reservation policy. They knew its importance as mean of social change. It is not surprising to find some voices coming from the SC community against faulty implementation of this policy but rarely such voice emerges from so-called backward class.
            As per Article 16(1) of the Constitution, there shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters of public employment.   However, the term ‘opportunity’ is defined purely in its literary sense. Irrespective of caste, a person living in a village which still in not connected with road and electricity, without water and school and devastated by flood every year does really have opportunity equal to as a person living in Mumbai have; irrespective of the fact whether comparison is made between upper caste and upper caste or Dalit/ OBC and Dalit/ OBC or upper caste and Dalit/ OBC. To say there is equal opportunity just on the basis that both the person can apply for the post in public office if they possess the required qualification is a non-sense. The vested-interests are spreading this myth. Hence, only caste can not be the criteria for ensuring equal protection of law as envisaged in Article 14 of the Constitution. There is need to devise Deprivation Index which should be based on set of different criteria to judge the backward class of citizen as envisaged in Article 16(4) of the Constitution and ensuring equal protection of law as envisaged in Article 14 of the Constitution. Neither Caste nor Income should be the sole criteria. Sooner we rectify the mistake of depending on single criteria of judging backwardness, earlier we can be able to contain the divide between two India which is burgeoning day by day.
            On seeing Prabhakar Ananad tryst with Tabela Coaching, I ponder over the story of Krishna and Sudama who came from extremely different economic background and studying in same Gurukool. Will it ever be reality in India, again?
            The movie ended without offering any practical solution to the problem of commercialistion of education and it had only a wishful ending.
Thank You.