Sunday, September 4, 2011

An Epilogue of Arakshan


Last night I saw the movie ‘Arkanshan. However, the issue of caste-based reservation remained in the background in the movie, albeit the way it has led to commercialization of education in India is indeed a novelty in the story.
            I could not find any thing in the movie which was derogatory to any community or caste. Some of the dialogues, which Saif Ali, as a protagonist,has said might have been the basis of objections raised by certain persons but they are not different from what is being said by the leaders from those castes/ class indulging in identity politics. The dialogues from his mouth in favour of reservation (caste-based) were written and acted so well that, lastly, it was more effective and appealing than the dialogue against reservation (caste-based) delivered by Pratik Babbar. The cacophony of the outcry against the movie leading to its ban in three States  reflected the prejudiced mind with which we take a issue of such enormity and also immaturity of the political leadership.
            The movie is misleading on one point. It linked 27 per cent with Scheduled Caste reservation. 27 per cent reservation for OBCs was the flash point in Indian polity which resulted into emergence of caste centric political parties. But, Scheduled Castes were not beneficiary of it. Reservation for SCs & STs has been a reality since independence and Indian society had come to the terms with it as an instrument to do away with years of injustice. 27 per cent reservation for OBCs to certain extent resulted in overall opposition to the reservation policy as such. The way backward classes were defined and the castes included at the time of every election and implementation of this policy as a mean to create vote-bank produced intense discontent. Reservation for SCs/ STs  is mistakenly viewed by  many as a new concession to the them in the aftermath of 27 per cent reservation . The film also held such view. In fact, many persons from dalit community feel that 27 per cent reservation acted against the interest of SCs. SCs are the real beneficiary of the reservation policy. They knew its importance as mean of social change. It is not surprising to find some voices coming from the SC community against faulty implementation of this policy but rarely such voice emerges from so-called backward class.
            As per Article 16(1) of the Constitution, there shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters of public employment.   However, the term ‘opportunity’ is defined purely in its literary sense. Irrespective of caste, a person living in a village which still in not connected with road and electricity, without water and school and devastated by flood every year does really have opportunity equal to as a person living in Mumbai have; irrespective of the fact whether comparison is made between upper caste and upper caste or Dalit/ OBC and Dalit/ OBC or upper caste and Dalit/ OBC. To say there is equal opportunity just on the basis that both the person can apply for the post in public office if they possess the required qualification is a non-sense. The vested-interests are spreading this myth. Hence, only caste can not be the criteria for ensuring equal protection of law as envisaged in Article 14 of the Constitution. There is need to devise Deprivation Index which should be based on set of different criteria to judge the backward class of citizen as envisaged in Article 16(4) of the Constitution and ensuring equal protection of law as envisaged in Article 14 of the Constitution. Neither Caste nor Income should be the sole criteria. Sooner we rectify the mistake of depending on single criteria of judging backwardness, earlier we can be able to contain the divide between two India which is burgeoning day by day.
            On seeing Prabhakar Ananad tryst with Tabela Coaching, I ponder over the story of Krishna and Sudama who came from extremely different economic background and studying in same Gurukool. Will it ever be reality in India, again?
            The movie ended without offering any practical solution to the problem of commercialistion of education and it had only a wishful ending.
Thank You.

No comments:

Post a Comment